Ways to fix a hard spot in your music
Once you know which spot to fix and what's wrong with it, you need a way to fix it. Here are the strategies band players use most, and what each one is good for. You won't need all of them in one practice. Try two or three, and if one isn't helping, switch to another.
If you haven't picked a spot and a goal yet, start with How to practice with a goal. If you know which skill needs work but not how to fix it, A practice fix-it list for every skill has ideas sorted by skill. Have a pencil and a metronome ready before you begin.
Make it smaller
Work in chunks
Break the spot into chunks of one measure or a few beats. Learn the first chunk, then the second, then play the two together. Keep adding chunks until the whole spot is back together. Chunks that start on a beat are easier to join.
Add one note at a time
For a fast run, play just the first two notes. When they're right, play the first three, then the first four, and so on. Each time you add a note, you play everything you've already learned again, so the start of the run gets lots of correct repeats.
Build from the end
Play only the last measure of the spot. Then start one measure earlier and play to the end, then two measures earlier. This way you always play into music you already know, and the end of the spot gets as much practice as the beginning.
Slow it down, then speed it up
Use a metronome
- Set the metronome to a tempo slow enough that you can play the spot correctly. It may be much slower than the music says, and that's fine.
- Play the spot correctly three times in a row.
- Move the metronome up 4 beats per minute and do it again.
- If it falls apart, go back to the last tempo that worked. Tomorrow, start a little below that tempo.
Try it here. The tempo ladder below has its own click and keeps track of each tempo you reach.
- 60
The metronome's Subdivision setting adds clicks for eighth or sixteenth notes between the beats. Fast notes are easier to place when you can hear the smaller parts of the beat.
You can do the same thing with the whole band in Band music. Lower the Tempo, then tap a note to start from that measure.
Five in a row
This game turns repeats into a contest with yourself. Put five coins (or paper clips, or erasers) on the left side of your music stand. Each time you play the spot correctly, slide one coin to the right side. If you make a mistake, all the coins go back to the left. You win when all five are on the right. If five is too many to start with, use three.
Change the rhythm to train your fingers
Long-short and short-long
When you can clap the rhythm but your fingers can't keep up, change the rhythm on purpose. Take a group of even notes and play them long-short, then short-long. Your fingers have to move quickly between some pairs of notes and get a little rest between others. Then play the notes evenly again. They usually feel easier.
Keep the same notes and fingerings, and change only the rhythm. You can also try other mixes, like long-long-short-short. This works on mallets too.
Two more ways to slow down the hard changes:
Play each note twice
Play every note in the spot twice before you move to the next one. It slows down the hard changes and gives you a moment to listen to the tone and tuning of each note. Then play the spot as written.Go back and forth
Often the problem is the move between two notes, not the notes themselves. Find the two notes where it goes wrong and play them back and forth slowly, as many times as you need. Then add the note before and the note after. This also works for a long slide move on trombone, or a move between two drums.
Separate the notes from the rhythm
When the notes and the rhythm are both hard, work on one at a time. These are also good for days when your lips or arms are tired, since you don't have to play.
Say the note names
Say the note names out loud while you press the fingerings or move the slide, without playing. Percussionists can say the stickings (R and L) while tapping them on their legs.Count and clap
Count the beats out loud (1, 2, 3, 4) while you clap the rhythm. Then count out loud while you finger the notes. If the counting is hard to remember, write it in pencil under the notes. The guide 1 e & a and other ways to count rhythm shows ways to count eighth notes, sixteenth notes, and triplets.Hiss the rhythm
This one is for wind players. Finger the notes while you blow air through your teeth with a hissing sound, starting each tongued note with a "t." Keep the air going through slurs. This puts your fingers, the rhythm, and your tonguing together without having to make a good sound yet, and it's quieter too.Sing it
Sing or hum your part. If you can sing it, you know how it's supposed to go, so it's easier to hear when your playing is off. Singing helps with tuning and phrasing, too.
Listen and perform
Hearing yourself the way other people hear you shows what's working and what still needs practice.
Record yourself
Record the spot on a phone or tablet, then listen with your music in front of you. Mark what you hear in pencil. Listen for what went well too, so you know what to keep doing.Play for someone
Play your spot, or the whole piece, for someone in your family. A friend from band can practice with you in person or on a video call. Playing for someone feels different from playing alone, so it's good practice for keeping going after a mistake.Practice somewhere new
Now and then, practice in a different room. Each room sounds and feels a little different, and getting used to that helps when you play in the band room or on a stage.
Which strategy should I try?
| If | Try |
|---|---|
| A fast run falls apart | Add one note at a time, long-short and short-long, or the metronome |
| One note change keeps going wrong | Go back and forth, or say the note names |
| The rhythm is wrong | Count and clap, write in the counting, or use the Subdivision setting on the metronome |
| You can play the spot by itself, but not in the piece | Build from the end, then play it with a measure before and after |
| It's right only some of the time | Five in a row |
| You can't tell what's wrong | Record yourself, or sing it |
| Your lips or arms are tired | Say the note names, count and clap, or hiss the rhythm, then play again later |
The printable practice plan lists these strategies as checkboxes, so you can mark the ones you tried. To fit them into a daily routine, see How to practice at home in 15 minutes.
From Band Trainer · bandtrainer.net/guides/fix-a-hard-spot