Ties vs. slurs: how to tell them apart

Both are curved lines. How to tell a tie from a slur at a glance, and what to play for each.

Ties and slurs are both curved lines that connect notes, and in a band book they can look almost the same. But they ask for different things. A tie changes a rhythm. A slur changes how you play a group of notes. Here's how to tell them apart.

Telling them apart quickly

The quick rule: look at the notes, not the line. If the curve joins two neighboring notes of the same pitch, it's a tie. Same pitch means the same line or space and the same sharp, flat, or natural, counting the key signature and any accidental earlier in the measure. If the curve joins different pitches, or one curve covers more than two notes, it's a slur.

TieSlur
ConnectsTwo neighboring notes of the same pitchTwo or more notes, usually different pitches
ChangesHow long the note lastsHow the notes are played
The second noteNot played again. Hold the first note through itPlayed as a new note, connected smoothly to the one before
Count it?Yes, add the values togetherCount normally
Often seenAcross bar lines, inside syncopationOver scales and melodies

Each tie curve joins just two notes. Ties can chain, though: a note tied to a note tied to another note is held through all of them, with a separate curve for each pair. A slur is one curve, and it often stretches over a whole group.

Ties: same note, held longer

A tie joins two notes of the same pitch into one longer note. You play the first note and hold it through the value of the second, with no new attack: no tonguing again and no striking again. Ties are about rhythm: they let a note last longer than one note value can show, or hold across a bar line. A tie also carries a sharp or flat across the bar line; see how long a sharp or flat lasts.

Tap a note to hear it
GGheld
Tied across the bar line: play one G and hold it for two beats.

The two notes have to be the same pitch. A curve from F to F♯ joins two notes in the same space, but F♯ is a different pitch, so that curve is a slur. Ties can also chain across several notes:

Tap a note to hear it
GGheldGheld
A chain of ties: play one G and hold it through all three values, five beats in all.

Ties also show up in the middle of a measure to make the beat easier to see. A quarter tied to an eighth sounds exactly like a dotted quarter (see how to count dotted quarter notes).

Tap a note to hear it
241&2&
Count beat 2, but don't play it: the tie means no new attack there. The next attack is on the & of 2.

Slurs: notes connected smoothly

A slur connects two or more notes, usually of different pitches. It doesn't change any rhythm. It tells you to play the notes smoothly and connected, with no gap between them. On a wind instrument that also means one breath for the whole slur. A slur can even come back to the pitch it started on, like G, A, G.

Tap a note to hear it
BCDE
Slurred: play B, C, D, and E as one smooth group. On woodwinds and valved brass, only the B is tongued. Trombone players may also need a soft legato tongue (see below).

How you move to the next note depends on your instrument:

  • Woodwinds: tongue only the first note under the slur, then keep the air moving while your fingers change notes.
  • Trumpet, horn, euphonium, and tuba: tongue only the first note and keep the air moving. Sometimes the valves change. Sometimes they don't, and you move to a different partial without changing valves (a lip slur).
  • Trombone: tongue the first note. When the next note is on a different partial, a lip slur can connect the two notes without the tongue. When both notes are on the same partial and only the slide moves, use a soft legato tongue ("doo") so the sound doesn't smear between notes. Your director will show you which to use.
  • Mallet percussion: every note is struck, so a slur marks a smooth, connected phrase. Rolled notes connect by keeping the roll going from bar to bar (see mallet rolls).

When you see both

A slur can contain a tie. For example, a slur might connect an E tied to another E, followed by D and C. Hold the tied E for both values, then move smoothly down to D and C. Read the tie first (it tells you the rhythm), then the slur (it tells you the articulation).

Tap a note to hear it
EEheldDC
The tie joins the quarter E and eighth E into one note, a beat and a half long. The slur over the whole group connects that E smoothly to D and C. On woodwinds and valved brass, only the first E is tongued.

If you can't tell which one you're looking at, check whether the two notes sit on the same line or space with the same sharp, flat, or natural. If they do, and the curve connects only those two, play it as a tie.

Ties in percussion parts

What a tie means in a percussion part depends on the roll marks (the slashes through the stem):

  • A roll tied to a note without roll marks: the roll keeps going up to that note and ends with one stroke on it, called the release.
  • A tie between two notes that both have roll marks: the roll keeps going through both values with no break, even across a bar line.
  • A tie between notes without roll marks: the first note is struck once, and the tied note isn't struck again. This is the usual case on mallets.

Look for the roll marks before you decide. A tie by itself doesn't tell you to roll. For more on reading rolls, see how to read snare drum music.

Try it

Tie or slur? Look at the notes the curve connects, not the curve itself.

Tap a note to hear it, then choose
1.
GG
2.
EF
3.
GAG
4.
CC
5.
FF♯

Practice

  • Go through one page of your band music with a pencil. Mark every tie with a "T" and every slur with an "S." If a curve doesn't fit either one, ask your director.
  • Clap each tied rhythm while counting out loud. Say the counts you hold through, but don't clap them.
  • Play a scale slurred in groups of two, then four, keeping the air steady between notes.

Build tied rhythms in Rhythm Builder to see where the next attack lands after a tie, then hear them in Rhythm Trainer.

Practice thisRhythm Builder: write what you hear

From Band Trainer · bandtrainer.net/guides/ties-vs-slurs