Playing in tune: hearing "beats" and matching pitch
Playing in tune isn't something you do once with a tuner at the start of rehearsal. You listen and adjust on every note. You can learn to hear it, and when two players hold the same note there's a clear sound to listen for.
What out of tune sounds like
When two players hold the same note and one is slightly out of tune, you often hear a wobble or pulse in the sound. These pulses are called beats. The farther apart the two pitches are, the faster the beats. As the pitches get closer, the beats slow down, and when they match, the pulse fades away and the sound turns smooth.
Listen for it next time your section tunes. A fast "wah-wah-wah" usually means you're far apart, and a slow pulse means you're close.
Beats are easiest to hear on long notes at the same pitch, played at a medium or soft volume. They can be harder to hear on very high or very low notes, when the two instruments sound very different, when someone uses vibrato, or when one player is much louder. A very slow pulse is also easy to miss. So not hearing beats doesn't prove you match. Before you decide, check that you're both on the same note in the same octave, that neither of you is much louder, and that a drone or a tuner agrees.
Which note and octave to match
Bands name tuning notes in concert pitch. The band's concert B♭ is written C for B♭ clarinet, trumpet, tenor sax, and treble-clef euphonium, G for alto and baritone sax, and F for horn. Flute, oboe, bassoon, trombone, bass-clef euphonium, and tuba read it as B♭. If that's new, see Concert pitch and transposing instruments.
Beats are clearest when both notes are in the same octave, but not every instrument can play the tuning note in the same octave. The examples on this page use concert B♭3. A trumpet or clarinet plays that easily, a concert flute can't play it at all (B♭3 is below its lowest note, which is middle C, or the B just below it on a flute with a B footjoint), and a tuba usually tunes an octave or two lower. Choose your octave on purpose: the same octave as the reference when you can, or the nearest one you play comfortably. When the band tunes, play the note and octave your director asks for. Two notes an octave apart still make beats when they're out of tune, but the beats are often fainter, so listen closely and check with a tuner.
Sharp or flat?
Beats tell you that you're out of tune, but not which way. To find out, move your pitch a little in one direction. If the beats get faster, you went the wrong way. If they slow down, keep going.
On most wind instruments, a tuning slide or joint changes the length of the tube:
| To go | Change | Examples |
|---|---|---|
| Lower (if you're sharp) | Make the tube a little longer | Pull out the main tuning slide (brass), the headjoint (flute), the barrel (clarinet), or the mouthpiece on the neck (saxophone) |
| Higher (if you're flat) | Make the tube a little shorter | Push the same part in |
On oboe and bassoon, the reed (and on bassoon, the bocal) does much of this work, so ask your teacher how to adjust. Mallet instruments can't be retuned by the player, and timpani are tuned with the pedal or the tuning handles.
A tuning slide sets your starting point. While you play, you also adjust with your embouchure and air, and on some instruments with alternate fingerings or slide positions.
Why your pitch moves
- Temperature (wind instruments): a cold instrument usually plays flat at first, and the pitch rises as your breath warms the air inside. A hot room can push you sharp. Warm up before you tune, and check again later.
- Dynamics: loud and soft playing can pull your pitch, but not in the same direction on every instrument or every note. Flutes tend to go sharp when they play loudly and flat when they play softly. Use a tuner to learn what your instrument does at different dynamics.
- Certain notes: every instrument has notes that tend sharp or flat, like trumpet written low D and C♯ (fingered 1-3 and 1-2-3), which run sharp. See the harmonic series and valves.
- Tired embouchure: late in rehearsal, a tired embouchure can let the pitch drift, often flat. Rest when you can.
- Air and setup: uneven air can make the pitch waver, and so can a moving jaw, a reed that doesn't suit you, or a mouthpiece that isn't in its usual spot. For long-tone practice, see how to get a better sound on trumpet, trombone, or flute.
Matching pitch in a section
- Listen to the player next to you, or the principal player, before you play.
- Hear the note in your head before you play it.
- Play a little softer than the person you're matching, so you can hear both notes and the beats between them.
- Adjust, listen again, and adjust again, in small steps.
To practice alone, play long tones against the drone and listen for the beats to slow down. On the drone page, pick your concert note and set Sound to Pure or Organ. Register then picks the octave of that note. With B♭ selected, Low plays B♭2, Middle plays B♭3 (the same concert B♭3 as the examples on this page), and High plays B♭4. Choose the octave closest to the note you're playing. The drone starts on the Warm sound, which mixes two slightly detuned voices, so it has a wobble of its own even when your pitch matches. Pure and Organ don't, so the beats you hear come from the gap between your pitch and the drone's.
Using a tuner the right way
A tuner helps you set your tuning slide and learn your instrument's tendencies. It shows the pitch it hears and nothing more. A needle that holds still means your pitch is holding still, not that your tone is good or that your air is even. Listen for those separately.
Watching the needle while you play can pull your attention away from the sound. Try this: play a long tone with your eyes closed, then open them and check the tuner. Over time you'll start to hear the difference before you see it.
Your ears, a reference note, and a tuner each check something different, so use all three. Listen for beats and blend, tune against the drone or another player, and check your pitch with the Band Trainer tuner. The tuner can show concert pitch or the note as it's written in your part.
Ear Trainer helps too. Hearing intervals clearly makes it easier to tell when something sounds "off" in a chord. Start with Recognizing intervals by ear.
From Band Trainer · bandtrainer.net/guides/playing-in-tune