The harmonic series and brass valve combinations
If you play a valved brass instrument, you've probably noticed something strange: the same fingering can play several different notes. With no valves pressed, a trumpet can play a low C, a G, the C in the staff, an E, a G, and more. This guide explains why, using something called the harmonic series, and shows how valves fit into the picture. For the beginning fingerings themselves, see the trumpet fingering chart.
Examples for: Trumpet in B♭, treble clef. The notes are written as in your part and sound a whole step lower.
What a partial is
When you buzz into a brass instrument, the air inside the tube vibrates. A tube of a certain length can vibrate in several ways: as one whole wave, in two halves, in three thirds, and so on. Each of those ways produces a different note, called a partial. Together, the partials form the harmonic series.
Your lips and air together choose which partial you play, and the buzz changes as you move from a lower partial to a higher one. Hearing the note you want before you play helps. That's why brass players talk about "finding the right partial."
| Partial | Trumpet, open (written) | Interval from the one below |
|---|---|---|
| 2nd | Low C | (starting note) |
| 3rd | G | Perfect 5th |
| 4th | C (3rd space) | Perfect 4th |
| 5th | E | Major 3rd |
| 6th | G | Minor 3rd |
| 7th | B♭ (about a third of a half step flat) | A little smaller than a minor 3rd |
| 8th | High C | A little larger than a major 2nd |
Notice that the partials get closer together as they go up. That's one reason high notes are harder to hit accurately: the next partial is only a small step away.
Three things to keep apart. The harmonic series is a model: its partials are exact ratios of one low pitch. Written notes, and the notes this guide plays when you tap them, use the nearest equal-tempered pitch. Real playing is a third thing: on a real horn, some partials sit a little sharp or flat of the written note. The 5th partial is a little flat, and the 7th is about a third of a half step flat. Players adjust with their lips, a slide, or another fingering.
That's why beginner charts leave out the open 7th partial. The B♭ above the staff is played with valve 1 instead, on a higher partial of that fingering that's much closer in tune. The open 7th partial is left out because it's out of tune, not because it can't be played.
How valves lengthen the tubing
A longer tube makes lower notes. Each valve, when pressed, sends the air through an extra loop of tubing, making the instrument longer and lowering every partial.
- Valve 2 lowers the pitch by a half step.
- Valve 1 lowers it by a whole step.
- Valve 3 lowers it by a step and a half (a minor 3rd).
Combining valves adds their effects. Valves 1 and 2 together lower the pitch about a step and a half, close to valve 3 alone, though the two aren't exactly the same length or the same in tune. 2 and 3 lower it two whole steps, 1 and 3 lower it two and a half steps, and all three lower it three whole steps.
So three valves make eight combinations, counting open. Because 3 and 1-2 land on about the same pitch, they make seven main pitch groups: open, and one to six half steps lower. That's enough to fill in the gaps between the partials.
Trombones do the same thing with the slide (see Trombone slide positions). First position, with the slide all the way in, is the starting position. Moving the slide out one position lowers the same partial by about a half step, so the seven positions match the seven pitch groups.
Why 1-3 and 1-2-3 run sharp
Each valve's extra tubing is measured to lower the pitch of the open horn by the right amount. When you press two or three valves, the horn is already longer, so each valve's tubing makes a smaller difference than it should. The result: the combinations 1-3 and 1-2-3 tend to play sharp unless the player adjusts.
How players fix it:
- Trumpet: use the third-valve slide ring to push the slide out on low D (1-3) and low C♯ (1-2-3). Many trumpets also have a first-valve slide trigger.
- Euphonium and tuba: many have a 4th valve. It adds tubing that lowers the pitch by a perfect 4th, so it can be used in place of 1-3. See the 4th valve on euphonium and tuba.
- Alternate fingerings: on some notes, valve 3 can replace 1-2, and it's often slightly lower. Your teacher can tell you when that's better.
French horn is different. The thumb lever on a double horn works a valve that switches the horn between its F side and a shorter B♭ side. It doesn't add tubing like a 4th valve, and it isn't a replacement for 1-3. On the B♭ side, the same written notes sit on lower partials, with their own fingerings. See the French horn thumb trigger.
Same fingering, different notes
Because every fingering has its own harmonic series, one fingering can play many notes. Open on trumpet plays C, G, C, E, and G. Valve 2 lowers all of those by a half step: B, F♯, B, D♯, F♯.
The opposite is also true: many notes can be played with more than one fingering. The E in the top space of the staff on trumpet can be played open (the 5th partial) or with 1-2 (on a higher partial of that fingering). This is where alternate fingerings come from, and they're useful for tricky passages and tuning.
Brass Trainer shows a written note and asks for its fingering or position, and it accepts common alternates. When you answer, you'll hear the note, so you can connect the fingering, the partial, and the sound.
Lip slur practice
A lip slur moves between partials on the same fingering, without using your tongue. Lip slurs are a common way to practice finding partials accurately.
- Start small. Slur between two neighboring partials, such as open G and the C above it on trumpet. Go slowly and keep the air steady.
- Go through the valve combinations. Play the same slur open, then with 2, then 1, then 1-2, then 2-3, then 1-3, then 1-2-3. Each step moves down by a half step.
- Add partials. When two-note slurs are easy, add a third partial above.
- Keep the pressure light. Let your lips and air make the change. Pressing the mouthpiece harder into your lips can pinch the sound and tire you out.
Trumpet players: for a step-by-step range routine built on these slurs, see how to play high notes on trumpet.
Example: G to C through the valve combinations
From Band Trainer · bandtrainer.net/guides/harmonic-series-valves